Selling Through an LLC or Trust

Overview

When property is held in an LLC, trust, or other entity, you face a structural choice that carries materially different tax consequences, transfer tax obligations, and buyer financing implications. You can sell the property out of the entity (an asset sale, where the LLC conveys the property by deed) or you can sell the entity itself (a membership interest transfer, where ownership of the LLC changes hands but the property stays inside it).

Each approach produces dramatically different outcomes. An entity sale may avoid transfer taxes entirely - saving potentially hundreds of thousands on high-value properties - but it narrows your buyer pool to all-cash purchasers, carries unknown liability risk for the buyer, and triggers anti-avoidance scrutiny under New York tax law. The optimal structure depends on the entity type, the property's tax basis, the buyer's financing needs, and the specific transfer tax regime that applies.

Botway helps sellers understand the transaction process and coordinate with the right professionals. Botway does not provide legal advice. Contract, ownership, estate, divorce, disclosure, and compliance questions should be reviewed with a qualified attorney.

Key Strategy

Entity sales can avoid transfer taxes but trigger anti-avoidance provisions. New York's transfer tax statutes include provisions that treat a transfer of a controlling interest (50% or more) in an entity that owns real property as a conveyance subject to transfer tax. This means the tax savings are not automatic - the structure must be carefully analyzed.

Most residential lenders will not finance entity purchases. They require a direct deed conveyance to the borrower. Entity sales are therefore limited to all-cash buyers or those with portfolio/commercial lenders willing to underwrite entity-level acquisitions. This significantly shrinks your buyer pool.

Title insurance complications arise with entity transfers. The existing title policy may not transfer to new ownership without insurer consent. The buyer may need a new owner's policy, which requires a full title search. Some title companies refuse to insure entity transfers entirely.

What To Do

Analyze whether the transfer tax savings from an entity sale justify the narrower buyer pool and added complexity. On a $5,000,000 property, transfer tax savings could exceed $100,000 - but only if the structure survives anti-avoidance scrutiny.

Consult with a tax attorney on whether your specific entity transfer triggers the controlling interest provision. The analysis depends on the entity structure, the percentage being transferred, and the nature of the entity's assets.

If pursuing an entity sale, target your marketing to all-cash buyers or buyers with commercial lending relationships. Do not waste time with conventionally financed buyers who cannot close an entity purchase.

If an entity sale is not feasible, conduct a standard asset sale where the LLC conveys the property by deed. This is simpler, accessible to all buyer types, and produces a clean title transfer.

Common Mistakes

Assuming an entity sale automatically avoids transfer taxes without analyzing New York's anti-avoidance provisions. The controlling interest rule can eliminate the intended tax benefit entirely.

Marketing an entity sale to a broad buyer pool that includes financed purchasers. Most residential lenders will not fund entity acquisitions - you are wasting time with unqualified prospects.

Failing to disclose all entity liabilities to the buyer. In an entity sale, the buyer inherits everything inside the LLC - including unknown liabilities, pending claims, and tax obligations that may not be visible on the surface.

Choosing an entity sale structure without weighing it against the reduced buyer pool. A 3-5% buyer pool reduction may cost more in final price than you save in transfer taxes.

Frequently Asked Questions

Should I sell my property or transfer the LLC?

Entity transfers - selling the LLC that owns the property rather than the property itself - can avoid transfer taxes, mortgage recording tax, and title insurance costs. However, they carry significant risks: the buyer inherits all entity liabilities, lender consent may be required, and some buyers or their attorneys reject entity purchases outright due to unknown liability exposure. The tax savings must be weighed carefully against reduced buyer pool size and legal complexity.

What are the tax consequences of selling my LLC instead of the property?

An entity transfer avoids transfer taxes and mortgage recording taxes - potentially saving hundreds of thousands on high-value properties. However, the buyer assumes all liabilities within the LLC, which most buyers resist. You also lose the stepped-up basis benefit for the buyer, which can reduce your pool of interested purchasers. The IRS may also recharacterize the transaction. Consult your tax advisor before choosing this route.

Can a buyer get a mortgage to purchase LLC membership interests?

Almost never with a conventional residential lender. Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac guidelines require a direct deed conveyance to the borrower - they will not underwrite a membership interest transfer. This limits your buyer pool to all-cash purchasers or those with portfolio lenders willing to finance entity-level acquisitions. Factor this constraint into your pricing and marketing strategy before committing to an entity sale structure.

Does New York's controlling interest transfer tax apply to my LLC sale?

If you transfer 50% or more of the ownership interests in an entity that owns real property, New York treats it as a taxable conveyance under the controlling interest provisions. This can eliminate the transfer tax savings that motivated the entity sale in the first place. The analysis depends on your entity structure, percentage transferred, and whether the entity holds other assets. Have your tax attorney evaluate before committing to this approach.

---

This article provides general educational information only. It is not legal, tax, financial, insurance, compliance, housing, brokerage, or professional advice. Rules, tax rates, obligations, enforcement practices, and market conditions vary by property, building, contract, municipality, and jurisdiction, and they change. Sellers should consult a qualified attorney, CPA, or other appropriate professional before making decisions based on their specific situation.