Seller Disclosure Obligations in New York - A Safe Operating Rule
Overview
“Caveat emptor” is sometimes summarized as “buyer beware,” but that shorthand is not a safe disclosure policy. For covered one- to four-family residential transfers, New York Real Property Law §462 creates an affirmative duty to complete and deliver the Property Condition Disclosure Statement before the buyer signs a binding contract. The current statute provides no $500 credit alternative. Separate federal duties require disclosure of known lead-based paint and lead hazards for most pre-1978 housing.
Contract duties, statutory exemptions, fraud rules, and the facts of a particular transaction require legal analysis. The brokerage should never tell a seller that silence alone eliminates disclosure risk.
Safe Operating Rule
- Comply with the current Property Condition Disclosure Act when the transfer is covered.
- Comply separately with federal lead-based-paint disclosure requirements when applicable.
- Do not conceal a condition or make an unsupported statement about the property's condition, repair history, renovation date, system age, permits, or violations.
- Route questions about exemptions, “as is” clauses, common-law duties, and contract representations to the seller's attorney.
- Correct marketing copy or a prior representation promptly when reliable information shows it is inaccurate.
Marketing and File Practice
Statements in listing copy, emails, showing conversations, and deal documents should be traceable to reliable property records or clearly identified as the seller's representation. When a fact cannot be verified, describe the missing information and direct the buyer to appropriate diligence instead of supplying a confident answer.
Keep copies of the signed statutory disclosures and evidence of when they were delivered. Use the current statutory form and current verified sources.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does caveat emptor mean a New York seller has no duty to disclose?
No. That statement is too broad. Section 462 imposes an affirmative disclosure duty for covered transfers, and federal lead-disclosure rules may also apply. Counsel must evaluate other duties and exemptions for the specific transaction.
Can a seller pay $500 instead of completing the PCDS?
No. The current text of §462 no longer contains that alternative.
What should the brokerage say when the legal duty is unclear?
State the verified statutory requirements, identify what is unknown, and refer the seller to transaction counsel. Do not improvise a legal conclusion from the phrase “buyer beware.”
Verified Sources
- New York Senate, Real Property Law §462 - fetched and read 2026-08-07.
- New York Senate, Real Property Law §463 - statutory transfer exemptions; accessed 2026-08-07.
- U.S. EPA, real-estate lead disclosure requirements - fetched and read 2026-08-07.
This article provides general educational information only and is not legal advice. A New York real-estate attorney should apply the law to the particular property, contract, and facts.
This is general information, not legal, tax or accounting advice. Every situation is different. Talk to a licensed attorney, accountant or tax professional before you act.
List for free, or go full service for 1%.
Use this playbook yourself, or let us run pricing, marketing and negotiation.