No-Fee vs Broker-Fee Listings After the FARE Act
The Short Answer
"No-fee" used to be a meaningful distinction because NYC tenants often paid a broker fee even when the landlord hired the broker. After the FARE Act (effective June 11, 2025), the party who hires the broker pays - so a landlord-listed unit is the landlord's cost, not yours, and "no broker fee to the tenant" is now closer to the baseline. You legitimately owe a broker fee only when you hire your own broker. All tenant fees must be disclosed in the listing and lease. The skill now is comparing true all-in move-in cost across listings and spotting fees that are really the landlord's broker cost in disguise.
Why This Matters
The FARE Act reset what "no-fee" signals, and renters who learned the market before June 2025 carry outdated assumptions. Previously, a "fee" listing meant you'd likely pay a month or 15% of annual rent to the landlord's broker; now that charge can't be passed to you. Understanding the shift means you stop treating a tenant broker fee on a landlord listing as normal - and start treating it as a red flag and a violation.
It also matters for honest cost comparison. With the broker fee removed from the tenant side of most listings, the real differentiator between apartments is the all-in move-in number and the monthly cost - not whether a listing is labeled "no-fee." Knowing how to compare those keeps you from overpaying or being steered by an outdated label.
The Money Math
On a $3,500/month unit with a landlord-hired broker, the FARE Act removes the old tenant fee:
| Cost | Before FARE Act | After FARE Act |
|---|---|---|
| First month | $3,500 | $3,500 |
| Security deposit (1 mo) | $3,500 | $3,500 |
| Tenant broker fee (15% of annual) | $6,300 | $0 |
| Move-in total | $13,300 | $7,000 |
The entire ~$6,300 difference is the eliminated tenant broker fee. If you choose to hire your own broker, you add that disclosed, agreed fee back - but it's now a fee you opted into for representation, and it's negotiable. The right comparison across listings is the all-in move-in total plus monthly cost, with a tenant broker fee appearing only when you hired the broker.
How People Get This Wrong
The first mistake is assuming "no-fee" still means what it did. Post-FARE, the absence of a tenant broker fee on a landlord listing is closer to the default - and a listing still quoting a tenant fee for the landlord's broker is the anomaly, not the norm.
The second is paying a relabeled fee. The landlord's broker fee renamed "amenity," "administrative," or "move-in" is still prohibited; the label doesn't change the substance.
The third is comparing listings on the "no-fee" label rather than the real numbers. Two listings can both be "no-fee" and differ by thousands in all-in move-in cost.
Where Renters Get Stuck
- Outdated "no-fee" assumptions post-FARE.
- Tenant broker fees still quoted on landlord listings.
- Relabeled pass-through fees at signing.
- Comparing on labels instead of all-in cost.
- Not knowing whom the broker represents.
Your Step-by-Step Playbook
- Establish whom the broker represents - landlord (their cost) or you (your cost, only if you hired them).
- Treat a tenant broker fee on a landlord listing as a red flag and a likely violation.
- Compare listings on all-in move-in cost: first month + one-month deposit + (only) a fee you owe + the $20 application fee.
- Watch for relabeled fees ("amenity/administrative/move-in") that are really the broker fee.
- Confirm fee disclosure - all tenant fees must be in the listing and lease (FARE Act).
- Report violations to DCWP with screenshots and messages.
Weighing Your Options
| Listing situation | Who pays the broker | Your all-in cost | Watch for |
|---|---|---|---|
| Landlord-listed, no tenant fee | Landlord | Lowest | Disguised fees at signing |
| Landlord-listed, tenant fee quoted | Should be landlord | Inflated/illegal | Challenge; report |
| You hire your own broker | You (by choice) | Higher, for your representation | Negotiate fee + scope |
| "Amenity/move-in" fee | Often the broker fee disguised | Hidden | Ask what it's for; refuse pass-throughs |
The NYC Rules That Apply
- FARE Act (eff. June 11, 2025): the hirer pays the broker; tenant owes a fee only if they hired the broker; all tenant fees disclosed in listing + lease; enforced by DCWP.
- HSTPA: one-month deposit cap; $20 application fee cap - the rest of the lawful move-in stack.
- Applies citywide to NYC residential rentals.
Run the Numbers
True all-in move-in cost (compare listings on this):
All-in = first month + 1-month deposit + $20 app fee + (broker fee ONLY if you hired the broker)
FARE Act effect on a landlord listing:
Tenant broker fee = $0 (the landlord's broker is the landlord's cost)
Common Mistakes to Avoid
- Assuming "no-fee" means what it used to.
- Paying a tenant broker fee on a landlord listing.
- Accepting relabeled pass-through fees.
- Comparing on labels, not all-in cost.
- Not confirming whom the broker represents.
- Not reporting violations.
The Thing Most People Miss
The FARE Act didn't just create more "no-fee" listings - it changed the default, so the meaningful question is no longer "is this no-fee?" but "did I hire this broker?" On a landlord's listing, the answer is no, and therefore you owe no broker fee, regardless of how the listing is labeled. That reframing collapses the old no-fee/fee distinction into a simple test and exposes the workarounds: any tenant broker fee on a landlord listing, or any "amenity/move-in" fee that's really the broker's pay, is the anomaly to challenge. Compare apartments on their true all-in cost, and treat a surprise fee as a violation, not a cost of doing business.
Renter Decision Layer
When this applies to you: while searching and comparing listings, and again at signing.
Red-flag signals:
- A tenant broker fee on a landlord's listing.
- "Amenity/administrative/move-in" fees appearing at signing.
- An agent vague about whom they represent.
Your quick checklist:
- Confirmed whom the broker represents.
- Verified no tenant broker fee on a landlord listing.
- Compared listings on all-in move-in cost.
- Refused relabeled pass-through fees.
- Ready to report violations to DCWP.
What to do next: compare on real numbers and challenge any disguised fee; see The FARE Act and The Move-In Cost Estimator.
Quick Questions
Does "no-fee" still mean anything? Less than it used to. Post-FARE, no tenant broker fee on a landlord listing is closer to the default; the real question is whether you hired the broker.
A landlord listing still shows a broker fee for me. Legal? Not if it's the landlord's broker. That fee can't be passed to you - challenge it and report it.
How should I compare listings now? On true all-in move-in cost: first month + one-month deposit + the $20 app fee + a broker fee only if you hired one.
Can a landlord rename the fee? No - "amenity/administrative/move-in" fees that are really the landlord's broker fee are still prohibited.
Where do I report a violation? NYC DCWP, with your listing screenshots and messages.
Citations
- NYC DCWP - FARE Act / broker fees: https://www.nyc.gov/site/dca/about/FAQ-Broker-Fees.page
- NY General Obligations Law §7-108 (deposit cap): https://www.nysenate.gov/legislation/laws/GOB/7-108
Related Reading
This is general information, not legal, tax or accounting advice. Every situation is different. Talk to a licensed attorney, accountant or tax professional before you act.
Looking for a place?
Browse what is open on Botway and save the ones you like.